Geoffrey try slain into the a riding crash into the 1186 and you can Constance partnered (2) Ranulph de- Blundeville, cuatro th Earl of Chester, with the step three rd February 1188, inside the a married relationship created from the Queen Henry 11. That it wedding deteriorated and you will Ranulph imprisoned Constance inside 1196. Rebellions was in fact sparked across Brittany on her behalf and you will Ranulph released her inside the 1198. Back into Brittany, Constance got her relationships annulled and soon after inside the 1198, she got Guy de Trips as their particular ‘second’ partner.
Constance passed away aged forty, (perhaps out of leprosy, maybe following childbirth so you’re able to dual girls) into the 5 th September 1201 during the Nantes
Although this was not an excellent consanguineous dating but among attraction, any first-knowledge matchmaking might have rendered relationships anywhere between Constance and any one of John’s brothers hopeless instead of an effective dispensation –– and that because of the party’s rank will have had to come from the fresh pope himself
The idea you to definitely Constance got an affair with John after the death of Geoffrey and you may before John’s wedding so you’re able to Isabella from Gloucester into the 1189, hence she are mother to Joanna is very contentious and you can has actually provoked much discussion within this genealogical circles.
You to definitely opinion out of an effective genealogist states that ‘the brand new journal ‘The Plantagenet Connection’ features blogged an ahnentafel regarding Age Plantagenet, wife regarding Henry V11, that gives Joanna’s mom’s title because Constance (perhaps misnamed Clemence?), Duchess out-of Brittany. This is the Constance who had been John’s sis-in-rules! Because of the well-recognized animosity anywhere between John and you will Constance along with her very own attempts to force their unique young man Arthur’s appeal as much as new throne regarding England was worried (therefore all know how disastrously you to definitely ended up!), I really get the suggested relationship a small difficult to consume. The fresh Constance one to record portrays cannot struck myself given that towards the exactly who John can potentially coerce toward sleep.’
‘ A theory who pick Joanna’s mother while the Constance doesn’t account fully for a highly important part of canon law. That would indicate that certain trace of one’s matter must positively attended right down to all of us, when it inside it brand new ask for it, the newest deliberations, and/or real dispensation itself. In so far as i have always been alert, absolutely nothing of your own kind is available.’
By the merely which have sex having John, let-alone hit your a baby, Constance will have situated a kissbrides.com hop over to this site first-degree relationship from attraction along with John’s siblings –– also John’s sibling Geoffrey
My personal view for just what it is well worth, would be the fact got Constance started mom out of Joanna she would surely has lead their own up in her own home along with her title is as well also known as Constance’s almost every other children by the Geoffrey (Eleanor, Reasonable Housemaid off Brittany, Matilda/Maud regarding Brittany and you can Arthur).
Agatha came into this world on 1168 inside the Chartley Castle, Staffordshire. It is infamous that she are a domme from John and several family members trees provide their, no matter if solitary, just like the mommy off Joanna. Very genealogists not are of the opinion it is simply conjecture that the woman is Joanna’s mother once the zero evidence otherwise information are present to demonstrate which.
One resource frequently provided was Sir William Dugdale, throughout the Baronage regarding England (1675-6). He states their supply is Dr David Howell’s ‘History of Wales’ (1584). Powell’s work is an increased release out of H Lloyd’s interpretation out-of ‘New Historie of Cambria’ because of the 12 th century Saint Caradoc of Llancarfan. A different source, ‘Magna Carta Barons’ of the Charles Browning, copyright 1969 as well as brands Agatha de Ferrers, daughter from Robert de- Ferrers, fourth Earl from derby, because the Joanna’s mom.
Although she can’t be entirely overlooked because the an applicant to possess mom away from Joanna, positively there would be particular shade from their own in the an excellent chronicle or other historical reference, when the she got in reality started mom of your wife away from the fresh Prince out of North Wales.